Category Archives: Zalma on Insurance

insurance, insurance coverage, insurance claims, insurance bad faith, claims, investigation, fraud.

When Judgment not Complete Appellate Jurisdiction Fails

When the District Court Dismissed the Counterclaims all of GEICO’s Claims Remained So No Appellate Jurisdiction Post 4577 In Government Employees Insurance Company, et al v.  Colin Clarke, M.D.,  No. 24-1611, United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit (October 29, … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Convicted of Felony Fraud You Lose the Right to Vote

Payment of Fines & Completion of Probation Reinstates Right to Vote Post 4576 To Restore Voting Rights The Felon Must Pay Fines of $546.00 In Florida Supreme Court Mediator Ethics Advisory Committee, ETH F-26-377, No. F-26-377 (October 29, 2026) citizen … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Failure of Immigrant to Exhaust Remedies Denies Bond

Castro Valdez Had an Available Administrative Appeal and Failed to Establish a Ground for Excusing  Post 4574 Administrative Review Permits the Agency to Apply its Expertise In Erwin Jordan Castro Valdez v. Warden, Otay Mesa Detention Center, No. 26-cv-06147-BAS-JLB, United … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Jury Found Prudential to be the Victim of Fraud

Insured’s Ordered to Pay Insurer for Fraud by the Insureds Post 4573 In The Prudential Insurance Company Of America v. Carol Gardina and George Gardina, No. 6:23-cv-1125-JSS-DCI, United States District Court, M.D. Florida, Orlando Division (October 22, 2026). THE JURY … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Tales From the Fraud Files

A Virtual Lunch with Barry Zalma  A Webinar  “Tales From the Fraud Files” Join us on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, from 12:30 to 1:30 PM ET for a lively, informal lunch and learn during International Fraud Awareness Week (November 15-21). … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Zalma’s Insurance Fraud Letter – November 1, 2026

ZIFL – Volume 30, Issue 21 Subscribe to ZIFL Here THE SOURCE FOR THE INSURANCE FRAUD PROFESSIONAL Zalma’s Insurance Fraud Letter (ZIFL) continues its 30th year of publication dedicated to those involved in reducing the effect of insurance fraud. ZIFL is … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

A Place to find everything you need about insurance claims

The Insurance Claims Library for You If you need an Insurance Claims Consultant or Expert Witness: (c) 2026 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc. Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

A Place to Learn Everything You Need to Understand Insurance Claims

If you need an insurance Claims Consultant or Expert Witness Contact

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Learn Everything You Need to Know About Insurance Claims

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Pleading Failed to State a Short and Plain Statement of the Claim.

Plaintiff Must Allege the Who, What, When, Where, and How requirements of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure  Post 4573 In Texoma Cowboy Church, Inc v. Church Mutual Insurance Company, S.I., Civil Action No. 7:26-CV-00062-O, United States District Court, N.D. Texas, … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Excellence in Claims Handling

Common Problems in a Jewelers’ Block Policy Investigation If you are not a subscriber you will read from this link until you reach the paywall end of this blog post as the free part of Excellence in Claims Handling. You … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

A Self-Insurance Plan Constitutes “Insurance”

Self Insurance is Excess Over Primary Insurance Post 4572 Employment Plan is Insurance Because it Transferred Risk and Contained Claim, Exclusion, and Priority Provisions. In Ajay Kolli, & c. et al. v. Kaleida Health, 2026 NY Slip Op 06167, No. … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

RICO Suit Against Law Firm & Health Care Pros Fails

UBER AND FEDEX FIGHT FRAUD Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) is Designed to Defeat Fraud Perpetrators In Uber Technologies, Inc., et al. v. Simon & Simon P.C., et al., Civil Action No. 25-5365, United States District Court, E.D. … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Removal to Federal Court Fails Because Party Is a State Citizen

Fraudulent Joinder Requires Return to State Court Hawai‘i Citizenship Triggered the Forum-Defendant Rule and Defeated Removal Post 4571 In Mary Sullivan-Bueche v.RLI Insurance Company; Finance Insurance Ltd; DOE Corporations 1-5; Doe Entities 1-5; John Does 1-5; And Jane Does 1-5, … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Plea to Fraud Stands to Maintain Probation

Failure to State Remorse Caused Her Petition To Remove Probation to be Rejected Probation for Workers’ Compensation Fraud Does Not Go Away Because Defendant claims the Admission was Made in Error Post 4570 In Morella Bombardini v. Board Of Psychology, … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Expert Report Must Be Admissible or it Will be Excluded

No Breach of Contract no Bad Faith A Party Cannot Designate One Witness While Submitting An Undifferentiated Product Of That Witness And An Undesignated Collaborator. Post 4568 In Dustin Cain; Amanda Cain v. State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, No. … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

John Madden and The US Patent and Trademark Office

Blockchain Fraud Detection Loses Protection John Earl Madden (April 10, 1936 – December 28, 2021) was an American Professional Football Coach and Sports Commentator in the National Football League Seeking Patent & Trademark Protection BLOCKCHAIN FRAUD Mr. Madden was more … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Supervisory Officials are not Individually Liable

Sovereign Immunity Defeats Suit Against Police Officers Post 4866 In Chad Lightfoot, et al. v. Progressive Direct Insurance Company, et al., Civil Action No. 26-434, United States District Court, E.D. Louisiana (October 9, 2026) Chad Lightfoot was involved in an … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Suit Must be Ripe When Filed

A Suit Filed Before the Claim Exists is Fatal Post 4870 In Louis Briggs v. Shaun Wimberly; Somerset Services, Inc.; And Wimberly & Associates, PLLC, and Louis Briggs v. Shaun Wimberly And Wimberly & Associates, PLLC Nos. 2024-CA-1471-MR, 2025-CA-1366-MR, Court … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

It is Very Expensive to not Read Your Policy

Failure to Read Application for Insurance & Policy is no Excuse for Failing to Protect Waiver Cannot be Inferred From Silence Post 4869 In Northfield Insurance Company v. Michigan 32, LLC, No. 25-1866, United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Plaintiff’s Reading of the Policy is Plaintiff’s Reasonable Allegations

CLASS ACTION THAT STATES A SIMPLE CLEAR AND PLAUSIBLE CAUSE OF ACTION SURVIVES Post 4868 In Sheila Marino v. Farmers New World Life Insurance Company, No. 2:25-cv-02200-JNW, United States District Court, W.D. Washington, Seattle (October 13, 2026) defendant Farmers New … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Alleged Defamatory Statements Must be Of and Concerning Plaintiffs

To Prove Defamation the Statement Must be Of and Concerning the Plaintiffs Post 4867 Court of Appeals When Reviewing a Summary Judgment, Takes as True all Evidence Favorable to the Nonmovant In Michael Moloney and Sergio Cantu v. United Services … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Zalma’s Insurance Fraud Letter – October 15, 2026

ZIFL – Volume 30, Issue 20 Subscribe to ZIFL Here THE SOURCE FOR THE INSURANCE FRAUD PROFESSIONAL Zalma’s Insurance Fraud Letter (ZIFL) continues its 30th year of publication dedicated to those involved in reducing the effect of insurance fraud. ZIFL is … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

District Court has Wide Discretion in Sentencing

Sentence for Stealing from Veterans Administration Reasonably Considers State Insurance Fraud & Arson Convictions Post 4863 In United States Of America v. Anthony Curtis Brewer, No. 26-10745, United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit (October 8, 2026) Anthony Curtis Brewer … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Title Insurance Only Insures Real Property

When a Seller Advised it Could Not Obtain Title to the Home Fraud Can’t be Proved A Manufactured Home is Personal Property Until it Becomes Real Property Post 4862 In Dale Johnson and Rose Johnson, Husband and Wife v. Stewart … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

RIFE WITH FRAUD ALLOWS DEMANDS TO ESTABLISH RESTITUTION

PSYCHIATRIST CONVICTED ON FOURTEEN FRAUD COUNTS AND RESTITUTION Post 4861 Attorney Argument Without  Evidence at Sentencing is Ineffective  In United States v. Gustavo Kinrys, Nos. 24-1592, 24-1716, United States Court of Appeals, First Circuit (September 21, 2026) Gustavo Kinrys, a … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Convicted of Insurance Fraud Seeks New Appointed Counsel & Mental Health 

Denial Of Mental Health Diversion And Probation Condition Were Affirmed The Denial Of Mental Health Diversion And The Challenged Probation Condition Were Affirmed. Post 4860 In The People v. Nicholas Daniel Stiles, A173483, A173646, California Court of Appeals, First District, … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Statements of Opinion Generally are not Actionable

Officer Entitled to Minimal Damages After Discipline for Wrong Doing  Post 4859 No Right to Abuse Prisoner In Darryl R. Wormuth, et al. v.  Prince George’s County, et al., No. 23-cv-2905-ABA, United States District Court, D. Maryland (September 29, 2026) Plaintiffs … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Suit Against State With No Duty of Care Owed by State

Fraudster’s Suit Dismissed Because State Owes No Duty A Person Arrested for Insurance – Fraud Later Dismissed  – Cannot Maintain Suit Against Officer and the State Post 4858 In Trevor Jared Smith v. Robert J. Perrault, Jr., and Florida Department … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Failure to Clarify Who’s on First Fraud Action Stalled

Fraud Suits Require Actual Clear Allegations Against Each Defendant Post 4857 Particularity for Fraud-Based Allegations Is Required In Franklin Construction Group, LLC v. Dean Bingham, Lundon Johnson, et al, No. 3:25-cv-01071, United States District Court, M.D. Tennessee, Nashville Division (September … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Short And Plain Statement Containing Enough Factual Matter To State A Facially Plausible Claim

Pro Se Plaintiff Failed to Make a Short and Plain Statement Post 4856 If Grounds For Dismissal Are Apparent From The Face Of The Complaint, A Court May Also Dismiss The Case on The Court’s Own Motion In Tak Lun Ng … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Announcement About False Claims Act Settlement Results in Damages Suit

Employee Report of Fraud Results in Damages Suit After Qui Tam Suit Settled No Statutory Hearing Right Arose Because No Dental Commission Complaint, License Suspension, Revocation, Or Sanction Occurred. Post 4855 In Abbas Mohammadi et al. v. William M. Tong … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Zalma’s Insurance Fraud Letter – October 1, 2026

From October 1, 1979 – 2026 Another Anniversary for Barry Zalma, Inc Post 4854 See the video here https://barryzalma.substack.com/welcome & https://zalma.com/blog & http://zalma.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/ZIFL-09-15-2026.pdf Subscribe to ZIFL Here THE SOURCE FOR THE INSURANCE FRAUD PROFESSIONAL Read the full issue of ZIFL at https://zalma.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/ZIFL-10-01-2026.pdf  … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Suing for Services Provided, and Paid for, is Fraud

Defendants Successfully Moved for Summary Judgment  Post 4854 The Party Alleging Fraud Must Establish A False Material Representation Or Concealment, Intent And Effect Of Deception, Resulting Damage, And Reasonable Reliance In Jeffrey Wayne Phillips v. Creative Website Studios, et al., … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Court Partially Limits Evidence to Present at Trial

Accused of 17 Counts Of Fraud Attempts to Keep Out Evidence of Crimes Post 4853 Court Refuses to Grant Most Motions in Limine In United States Of America v. Seth Allen Aikens, II, Criminal No. 22-119, United States District Court, … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

The Mortgage Clause in a Property Policy

Dealing with a Mortgagee when faced with a Fire Loss If you are not a subscriber you will read from this blog until you reach the end of this blog post as the free part of Excellence in Claims Handling. … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Fraudulent Health Insurance Benefits Are Unjust Enrichment

Court Refuses to Honor an Illegal Agreement Post 4854 HE claimed Ms. Kiraga had received money under such circumstances that in equity and good conscience she ought not be allowed to keep but the Equities Remained with her.  In HE … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Unwise for a Appellant to Represent Himself.

Inadequately Briefed Issues Defeats Appeal Post 4852 Issues on Appeal Must be Adequately Briefed In Emy Ojekwe v. Connecticut Transit District Consortium, No. AC 47389, Court of Appeals of Connecticut (September 22, 2026) Emy Ojekwe alleged that he was injured … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Restitution Sentence Affirmed

Psychiatrist Who Was Convicted of Fraud Asked the First Circuit to Reduce his Punishment Post 4851 Fraud to Private and Public Health Insurers Doesn’t Pay In United States v. Gustavo Kinrys, Nos. 24-1592, 24-1716, United States Court of Appeals, First … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment

Payment and Performance Bonds Are Not Designed to Profit from Failure to Perform

The Collateral-Source Rule is a Narrow Exception to the Prohibition Against Double Recovery Post 4850 A Surety Stands In The Principal’s Shoes And May Assert The Principal’s Defenses. In Hudson Insurance Company v. Archer Western Federal, JV, No. 1:24-cv-544 (PTG/IDD), … Continue reading →

Posted in Zalma on Insurance | Leave a comment