Fraudulent Joinder Requires Return to State Court

Hawai‘i Citizenship Triggered the Forum-Defendant Rule and Defeated Removal
Post 4571
In Mary Sullivan-Bueche v.RLI Insurance Company; Finance Insurance Ltd; DOE Corporations 1-5; Doe Entities 1-5; John Does 1-5; And Jane Does 1-5, No. 26-cv-00291-DKW-KJM, United States District Court, D. Hawaii (October 22, 2026) Mary Sullivan-Bueche, an Oregon citizen working on assignment in Hawai‘i, was injured on May 18, 2024, when an unlicensed and uninsured motorist struck a vehicle supplied through her employer, Group 70 International, Inc. (G70)
G70 had purchased an automobile policy allegedly providing $1 million in liability coverage for “any auto.” Sullivan-Bueche alleged that the responsible defendant failed to offer or explain uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage options and later denied her demand for uninsured-motorist benefits.
She sued RLI and Hawai‘i-based Finance Insurance Ltd. in Hawai‘i state court for declaratory and injunctive relief and damages. RLI removed the case on diversity grounds, and Sullivan-Bueche moved to remand under the forum-defendant rule. Defendants responded that Finance Insurance had been fraudulently joined.
LAW
A state-court action may be removed only if the federal court would have had original jurisdiction and removal is timely. Diversity jurisdiction requires more than $75,000 in controversy and complete diversity between every plaintiff and defendant.
Fraudulent joinder is a narrow exception: a resident defendant may be disregarded only when the plaintiff obviously cannot state a claim against that defendant under settled state law. The removing party must prove fraudulent joinder by clear and convincing evidence, and any doubt concerning removal is resolved in favor of remand. If a pleading defect could be cured by amendment, fraudulent joinder is not established.
DISCUSSION
Sullivan-Bueche argued that removal was barred because Finance Insurance is a Hawai‘i citizen. Defendants argued that Finance Insurance was only the broker, not the insurer, and could not be liable under the cited provisions of Hawai‘i insurance law.
The court rejected that showing as insufficient. An insurance broker may independently owe the insured a duty to exercise reasonable skill, care, and diligence in procuring coverage. More importantly, the fraudulent-joinder inquiry was not whether Sullivan-Bueche would ultimately prevail, but whether Finance Insurance could possibly be liable under any theory.
Even if the existing complaint did not adequately plead such a claim, Defendants did not show that amendment would be futile under Hawai‘i’s liberal amendment rules.
ANALYSIS
The decision turns on the demanding burden for proving fraudulent joinder. Defendants focused on weaknesses in the pleaded statutory theory, but that did not eliminate other potential broker-liability theories or the possibility of a curative amendment.
Because Finance Insurance could not be disregarded, its Hawai‘i citizenship triggered the forum-defendant rule and defeated removal. The court therefore had no need to decide whether Defendants waived the fraudulent-joinder argument by omitting it from the notice of removal.
CONCLUSION
The court granted Sullivan-Bueche’s motion and remanded the action to the Second Circuit Court of the State of Hawai‘i under 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c).
ZALMA OPINION
Federal courts have limited jurisdiction. If a suit is brought against citizens of two or more states there is no jurisdiction federal jurisdiction. The suit as filed was brought by a citizen of Oregon against a citizen of Hawaii, was clearly impossible to join the litigants into federal jurisdiction. Although it is possible that Sullivan-Bueche has not yet stated a claim, this is an insufficient basis to find a party has been fraudulently joined.
As Sullivan-Bueche offers in reply, there are various potential causes of action against Finance Insurance that her Complaint may not allege. Because the heavy burden of establishing fraudulent joinder falls on Named Defendants, and because Named Defendants have not satisfied that burden, the Court did not find that Sullivan-Bueche fraudulently named Financial Insurance in this action. Accordingly, Sullivan-Bueche’s Motion is granted.

(c) 2026 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.
Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe
Go to X @bzalma; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/account/content?type=all; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk.

